A case manager’s view on the rising cost and shrinking supply of care workers
A few weeks ago, I was tasked with recruiting a small team of carers for a client with complex physical and cognitive needs. The care package was funded by the local authority. We needed consistent, experienced support workers to cover seven days a week, a mix of personal care, companionship, and clinical awareness. After three weeks, dozens of phone calls, and trawling through agencies and self-employed directories, we had no one in place. Not because there weren’t carers out there, but because we simply couldn’t meet their rates.
This is becoming the norm.
Across the UK, the cost of securing care, whether through agencies or self-employed personal assistants, has risen sharply in recent years. Hourly rates are increasingly fluid, changing based on demand, region, and even time of year. In many areas, it’s now common to see agency rates in excess of £30–£35 per hour for complex care, while experienced self-employed carers are quoting between £20–£28 per hour (or more) in the open market. Yet funding panels appear to continue to approve care packages based on outdated rate assumptions that haven’t moved in years.
As a case manager, I find myself caught between two realities: the expectations of fee payers, who are tasked with balancing shrinking public budgets, and the marketplace reality.
There’s also the issue of sheer availability. The care sector faces a recruitment crisis. Demand is rising rapidly, fuelled by an ageing population and the shift toward home-based support, but the workforce isn’t keeping up. Post-pandemic burnout, Brexit-related workforce losses, and a chronic lack of incentives to join or stay in care are all taking their toll.
Good carers, especially those who are self-employed, are being booked up months in advance. They’re also becoming more selective, and understandably so. They want clients who are safe, well-matched, and financially viable. Unfortunately, our public systems are struggling to provide that stability.
One workaround used by families is to recruit self-employed carers directly. But this raises another concern, (one that we have explored previously): how do we ensure these carers are appropriately trained, insured, and safe to work with vulnerable people? As case managers, we’re often asked to oversee or support these arrangements, but without formal oversight structures, the burden of vetting and quality assurance falls on individuals or families who may not know what to look for.
We support people with acquired brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and other life-changing conditions. These are not low-needs packages. Yet there is a danger of becoming increasingly reliant on informal arrangements that lack the safeguards we would expect in any other clinical or social care setting.
This isn’t about blaming carers for charging more, they do vital, often exhausting work and deserve to be paid fairly. But if we want community-based care to remain viable, the system needs to evolve. That means:
Funding care packages at rates that reflect the real cost of delivery in today’s market.
Providing clearer guidance around acceptable rate bands for self-employed carers, with regional adjustments.
Creating frameworks to support the vetting, training, insurance and oversight of self-employed workers, especially when sourced by families.
Recognising that good care isn’t just about hours covered, but about quality, consistency, and sustainability.
Until then, we’ll continue to face a stark mismatch between what’s needed and what’s possible. And the people who’ll feel that gap the most are the very clients we’re all here to serve.

